The Candy Bowl

In Episode 657, Benito Cereno joined your hosts for the annual Halloween Spooktacular to rank candy in the classet bracket format of October Oddities.

Seeds

1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
2. Snickers
3. Kit Kat
4. Hershey Bar
5. M&M’s (Peanut)
6. M&M’s (Plain)
7. Twix
8. Twizzlers
9. Skittles
10. Gummy Bears
11. Reese’s Pieces
12. Three Musketeers
13. Sour Patch Kids
14. Jolly Ranchers
15. Milky Way
16. Almond Joy
17. Butterfinger
18. Mounds
19. Hershey’s Kisses
20. Mr. Goodbar
21. Crunch Bar
22. Tootsie Rolls
23. Smarties
24. Candy Corn

Qualifying Round

Because there were 24 competitors, the bottom 16 seeds had to battle it out in a qualifying round:

Match	Entrants		Winner
1	16. Almond Joy	17. Butterfinger	Almond Joy
2	9. Skittles	24. Candy Corn	Skittles
3	13. Sour Patch Kids	20. Mr. Goodbar	Mr. Goodbar
4	12. Three Musketeers	21. Crunch Bar	Crunch Bar
5	15. Milky Way	18. Mounds	Milky Way
6	10. Gummy Bears	23. Smarties	Gummy Bears
7	14. Jolly Ranchers	19. Hershey’s Kisses	Hershey’s Kisses
8	11. Reese’s Pieces	22. Tootsie Rolls	Reese’s Pieces

Main Bracket

Round of 16

Round of 8

Final 4

Championship

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Almond Joy

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Skittles

Twizzlers

Skittles

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

M&M’s (Peanut)

Hershey Bar

Mr. Goodbar

Mr. Goodbar

M&M’s (Peanut)

M&M’s (Peanut)

Crunch Bar

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Reese’s Pieces

Snickers

Milky Way

Milky Way

Twix

Twix

Gummy Bears

Milky Way

Reese’s Pieces

Kit Kat

Hershey’s Kisses

Kit Kat

Reese’s Pieces

M&M’s (Plain)

Reese’s Pieces