Segments
| Name | Notes | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Patreon Thanks | WRA Patreon launched December 2014 | Current |
| Earth Shattering News | Evolved into Check and Recs | Past |
| Checks and Recs | What's happening in the hosts lives, what they recommend | Current |
| The Hundo Club | As a reward from 2011's Pledge Drive, people who donated could be a third-chair co-host | Past |
| MMA Update | After complaining that MMA is boring, Chris started training MMA and gave updates on the gym and Dojo | Past |
| Health Situation | Past | |
| Comics Reviews | Current | |
| A LootCrate Ad | Podcast sponsor reads | Past |
| Interview | See Guests | Current |
| Comics Roundtable | As part of WRA becoming the official podcast of ComicsAlliance, members of the CA talk about current events in comics | Past |
| Twitter Questions | Past | |
| Listener Questions | Current | |
| Big Ups To All My Haters | Past | |
| Making Fun of a Swimsuit Issue | Past | |
| Tales From the Comic Shop | Chris relates stories from working in a comic shop | Past |
| What's Pissing Us Off This Week | Past | |
| Love Haters | Past | |
| Letters From Thrasher | Chris presents a dramatic reading from the letter pages of Thrasher Magazine | Past |
| Every Story Ever | Ranking every comic story from best to worst | Moved to special episodes |
| Word Heavyweight Champion | Ranking the top 100 comic book quotes | Past |
| Panel President | Ranking the best comic book characters | Past |
| This or That | The hosts choose between 2 (or more) listener-submitted alternatives | Past |
| Great Indoor Fight | Listeners submit a single character and the hosts pair up submissions and decide who would win a fight. | Past |
| FalChris and the Wilson Soldier | Aka "The Great Gruenwald Re-Read" AKA "Gruenies": Chris and Matt re-read the entire 137+ issue run of Captain America written by Mark Gruenwald. Replaces the Interview and post-interview segments once a month. | Past |
| Battle of the Decades | Listeners submit two characters, products, teams, publishers, themes, etc. and Matt and Chris decide who "won" each decade. | Past |
| Chat Central | Goth-heads Matt and Chris talk about what the've been up to when they aren't watching Gotham, which they do all the time. | Neighborhood Watch 600 |
| Previously on Neighborhood Watch | Matt goes through the entire "Previously on Gotham" segment and explains everything that happened because he's seen every episode. | Neighborhood Watch 600 |
| Show Info | The Goth-heads fill in the Cybergoths on the writers and directors of each episode. | Neighborhood Watch 600 |
| Grading Gotham | Ratings for every episode are ranked from F to A to S to G. So far every episode has been ranked an increasingly higher G+. | Neighborhood Watch 600 |
| Every Dracula Ever | Chris, Benito and Elle Collins must rank every Dracula across every medium. | 613 |
| Jurgies into Mystery | Chris and Matt read every issue of the Dan Jurgens run on Thor | Current |
| Thursday Night Raw | The boys rank the rawest moments in comics. | Past |
| I to X of Swords | The boys rate swords, but don't rank them. | Current |
Note: All segments up to This or That, regardless of status, appear in Episode 500.